Intro

The grids below are ySTR results, ie from yDNA37, yDNA67, yDNA111 test from FamilyTreeDNA.
From such tests you also get at least a predicted haplogroup (red), ie your position on the Haplotree of mankind.
Any non-red results in the Haplogroup column have been specifically tested (or inferred from close matches), either via individual, or SNP pack tests, which test the kit against known SNPs (positions on the tree) or via the BigY test which discovers SNPs for new branches on the tree.
For the relative positions on the tree, some age estimates, check out the Haplogroups section of this site.

RUNCIMAN Lineage 1 (Haplogroup I1)

Full RUNCIMAN DNA results - lineage 1 (I1)
123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106107108109110111
Kit IdentifierHap3
9
3		3
9
0		1
9
/
3
9
4		3
9
1		3
8
5
a		3
8
5
b		4
2
6		3
8
8		4
3
9		3
8
9
-
1		3
9
2		3
8
9
-
2		4
5
8		4
5
9
a		4
5
9
b		4
5
5		4
5
4		4
4
7		4
3
7		4
4
8		4
4
9		4
6
4
a		4
6
4
b		4
6
4
c		4
6
4
d		4
6
0		Y

G
A
T
A

H
4		Y
C
A

I
I

a		Y
C
A

I
I

b		4
5
6		6
0
7		5
7
6		5
7
0		C
D
Y
a		C
D
Y
b		4
4
2		4
3
8		5
3
1		5
7
8		3
9
5
-
S
1
a		3
9
5
-
S
1
b		5
9
0		5
3
7		6
4
1		4
7
2		4
0
6
-
S
1		5
1
1		4
2
5		4
1
3
-
a		4
1
3
-
b		5
5
7		5
9
4		4
3
6		4
9
0		5
3
4		4
5
0		4
4
4		4
8
1		5
2
0		4
4
6		6
1
7		5
6
8		4
8
7		5
7
2		6
4
0		4
9
2		5
6
5		7
1
0		4
8
5		6
3
2		4
9
5		5
4
0		7
1
4		7
1
6		7
1
7		5
0
4		5
5
6		5
4
9		5
8
9		5
2
2		4
9
5		5
3
3		6
3
6		5
7
5		6
3
8		4
6
2		4
5
2		4
4
5		Y

G
A
T
A

A
1
0		4
6
3		4
4
1		G
G
A
A
T
1
B
0
7		5
2
5		7
1
2		5
9
3		6
5
0		5
3
2		7
1
5		5
0
4		5
1
3		5
6
1		5
5
2		7
2
6		6
3
5		5
8
7		6
4
3		4
9
7		5
1
0		4
3
4		4
6
1		4
3
5
Modal132214101313111411121128168981123162028121415151010192114151618343612101181515812108991222251510121216813242013131112111212113212817122301911121213119111110121231111321161010{26,28}1518112517{13,14}152512231812142091211
Lineage 1 - a,b,c, d
Ancestral lines from Berwickshire, and East Lothian
Jerry (R-2)
I-A11399
1322141013131114111211281689811231620281214151510101921141516183436121011815158121089912222515101212168132420131311121112121132.2128180230011121213119111110120011130010102815181125013142512231812142091211
David (R-1)
I-A11399
1322141013131114111211281689811231620281214151510101921141516183436121011815158121089912222515101212168132520131311121112121133.21281712230191112121311911111012123111132116101026141811241713152512231812142091211
Jere (R-18)
I-M170
13231410131311141112112816898112316202812141515111019211415161834361210118151581210899122225151012121681325201313111211121211
Peter (R-12)
I-A11393
1322141013131114111211281789811231620281214151511101921141516183436121011815158121089912222515101212168132420131311121112121132.21281702301911121213119111101212011130010102615181125171415251223181201991211
80898013221410131311141112112816898112316202812141515111019211415161834361210118151581210899122225151012121681324201313111211121211
D A. (R-19)
I-A11400
13221410131311141112112816810811231620281214151511101921141516183536121011815158121089912222515101212168132420131311121112121132.21381712240011121213119111110121200132116101025151811251714152512231812142091211
RJW (R-11)
I-M253
13221410131311141112112816898112316202812141515101019211415161834361210118151581210899122225151012121781324201313111211121211
Jim (R-10)
I-A9096
1322141013131114111211281689811231620281214151510101921141616183436121011815158121089912222515101212178132420131311121112121132.212817122301911121213119111110121201113016101027161811251714152512231812142091211
W R-2013221410131311141112112816898112316202812141515101019211415161834361210118151581210899122225151012121681324201313111211121211
Kevin (R-8)
I-A9096
1322141013131114111211281689811231620281214151610101921141516183436121011815158121089912222515101212168132420131311121112121133.2128170230191112121311911111012123111132116101028151811241713152512231812142091211
Jim (R-7)
I-M253
13221410131311141112112816898112316202812141515101019211415161834361110118151581210899122225151012121681324201313111211121211
Alan (R-17)
I-M253
13221410131311141112112916898112316202812141515101019211415161834361310118151581210899122225151012121681324201313111211121211
NB the marker panel from 68-111 has been extracted from YFull.com's analysis of the BigY BAM files

RUNCIMAN Lineage 2 (Haplogroup R1b1)

Full RUNCIMAN DNA results - R1b1 Haplogroup
123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106107108109110111
Kit IdentifierHap3
9
3		3
9
0		1
9
/
3
9
4		3
9
1		3
8
5
a		3
8
5
b		4
2
6		3
8
8		4
3
9		3
8
9
-
1		3
9
2		3
8
9
-
2		4
5
8		4
5
9
a		4
5
9
b		4
5
5		4
5
4		4
4
7		4
3
7		4
4
8		4
4
9		4
6
4
a		4
6
4
b		4
6
4
c		4
6
4
d		4
6
0		Y

G
A
T
A

H
4		Y
C
A

I
I

a		Y
C
A

I
I

b		4
5
6		6
0
7		5
7
6		5
7
0		C
D
Y
a		C
D
Y
b		4
4
2		4
3
8		5
3
1		5
7
8		3
9
5
-
S
1
a		3
9
5
-
S
1
b		5
9
0		5
3
7		6
4
1		4
7
2		4
0
6
-
S
1		5
1
1		4
2
5		4
1
3
-
a		4
1
3
-
b		5
5
7		5
9
4		4
3
6		4
9
0		5
3
4		4
5
0		4
4
4		4
8
1		5
2
0		4
4
6		6
1
7		5
6
8		4
8
7		5
7
2		6
4
0		4
9
2		5
6
5		7
1
0		4
8
5		6
3
2		4
9
5		5
4
0		7
1
4		7
1
6		7
1
7		5
0
4		5
5
6		5
4
9		5
8
9		5
2
2		4
9
5		5
3
3		6
3
6		5
7
5		6
3
8		4
6
2		4
5
2		4
4
5		Y

G
A
T
A

A
1
0		4
6
3		4
4
1		G
G
A
A
T
1
B
0
7		5
2
5		7
1
2		5
9
3		6
5
0		5
3
2		7
1
5		5
0
4		5
1
3		5
6
1		5
5
2		7
2
6		6
3
5		5
8
7		6
4
3		4
9
7		5
1
0		4
3
4		4
6
1		4
3
5
Lineage 2a
Line of James & Agnes (HERRIOT) RUNCIMAN of Ayton/Dunbar
Modal132615101214121211121328188101111261519281516171710111923151520173738111200000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
Don (R-3)
P-25
1326151012141212111213281881011112615192815161717101119231515201737381112
Phil (R-4)
R1b1a2
1326151012141212111213281981011112615192815161717101119231515201737381112
(R-6)
R1b1a2
1327151012141212111213281881011112615192815161717101119231515201737371112
Rodney (R-5)
R1b1a2
132615101214121210121328
Lineage 2b
Line of John & Isabella (PILMUIR/PALMER) RUNCIMAN of Spott, Coldingham, Innerwick, Coldstream
Neil (R-9)
R-M269
1324141011141212141313301991011112515193115151718
Lineage 2c
John & Susan (DONALDSON) RUNCIMAN of Inchture, Perthshire
(R-14)
R1b1a2
132514111114121211131328169101111261419321515171711111922161518183738111211915168101081010122323181012121681222201312111411111212
Lineage 2 - other
Scott (R-15)
R1b1a2
132414111114131213131429179101111231519291617171711111923181518173436131211915168101081010122123161012121681220221412111311111212

RUNCIMAN Lineage 3 (Haplogroup E1b1)

Full RUNCIMAN DNA results - E1b1 Haplogroup
123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106107108109110111
Kit IdentifierHap3
9
3		3
9
0		1
9
/
3
9
4		3
9
1		3
8
5
a		3
8
5
b		4
2
6		3
8
8		4
3
9		3
8
9
-
1		3
9
2		3
8
9
-
2		4
5
8		4
5
9
a		4
5
9
b		4
5
5		4
5
4		4
4
7		4
3
7		4
4
8		4
4
9		4
6
4
a		4
6
4
b		4
6
4
c		4
6
4
d		4
6
0		Y

G
A
T
A

H
4		Y
C
A

I
I

a		Y
C
A

I
I

b		4
5
6		6
0
7		5
7
6		5
7
0		C
D
Y
a		C
D
Y
b		4
4
2		4
3
8		5
3
1		5
7
8		3
9
5
-
S
1
a		3
9
5
-
S
1
b		5
9
0		5
3
7		6
4
1		4
7
2		4
0
6
-
S
1		5
1
1		4
2
5		4
1
3
-
a		4
1
3
-
b		5
5
7		5
9
4		4
3
6		4
9
0		5
3
4		4
5
0		4
4
4		4
8
1		5
2
0		4
4
6		6
1
7		5
6
8		4
8
7		5
7
2		6
4
0		4
9
2		5
6
5		7
1
0		4
8
5		6
3
2		4
9
5		5
4
0		7
1
4		7
1
6		7
1
7		5
0
4		5
5
6		5
4
9		5
8
9		5
2
2		4
9
5		5
3
3		6
3
6		5
7
5		6
3
8		4
6
2		4
5
2		4
4
5		Y

G
A
T
A

A
1
0		4
6
3		4
4
1		G
G
A
A
T
1
B
0
7		5
2
5		7
1
2		5
9
3		6
5
0		5
3
2		7
1
5		5
0
4		5
1
3		5
6
1		5
5
2		7
2
6		6
3
5		5
8
7		6
4
3		4
9
7		5
1
0		4
3
4		4
6
1		4
3
5
Lineage 3a
Line of William & Janet (PAXTON) RUNCIMAN of Nth Berwick then Borthwick
R-13 Runciman
E1b1b1
132413101718111312131130159911112614213214161717911192116121819313312101081516811108121002324181112121671222181213121411111111

Discussion - overall project

With RUNCIMAN being an occupational surname, we had low expectations of finding m/any matches between assorted paper trail lineages.

Initially, the RUNCIMAN project participants all represented lines originating in the Scottish Borders or East Lothian, but in three separate haplogroups, ie unrelated.
Results (May 2010) now show another lineage within the R1b1 haplogroup, but as there is a mismatch between the paper trail and dna results from two representatives from what was thought to be the same line, further investigation, and another representative from another line, was needed before any conclusions can be reached.

Results (Feb 2011) added a new haplogroup into the mix, with an E1b1b1 participant (who was expected to match Peter (R-12) in Lineage 1 - so much for that theory).

Results late 2012 added an unrelated I1 haplogroup line into the mix, from Stirlingshire/Lanarkshire. No matches to the existing participants, which isn't altogether unexpected given the occupational nature of the surname.

Jun 2014 added another set of East Lothian results - and another match in Lineage 1, helping to confirm the dna signature for lineage 1d, Alexander and Janet (HENDRIE) RUNCIMAN of Meikle Pinkerton, joined in Aug 2014 by another matching representative of this line.

It would be interesting to see how the other lines known to exist, match, or not, with these, so all participants welcome.